Equity Lifestyle Properties at a Glance

Cox Planning Solutions Expedites Post-Storm Repairs for Equity Lifestyle Properties

Equity Lifestyle Properties is a major real estate company with a portfolio of over 450 communities in 35 U.S. states and British Columbia, controlling over 170,000 sites. Key to their success in the hospitality sector is prioritizing guest experience.

The Problem

The Problem That Equity Lifestyle Properties Faced

Equity Lifestyle Properties was dealing with significant storm damage at a large campsite near Yosemite. This damage included flooding, destruction of buildings, and near-collapse of a vital pedestrian bridge carrying essential utilities. The extensive repair work required careful environmental permitting, as Workers would need to dewater the South Fork of the Tuolumne River to properly rebuild the damaged bridge and sewer line. The process was further complicated due to involvement from multiple environmental agencies and legislation like the Clean Water Act and the Endangered Species Act. 

 

Working with the right environmental consultant would be critical to a successful and compliant outcome. 

“We’re in the hospitality business,” explains Mike Sukel of Equity Lifestyle Properties. “So guest experience is everything. Keeping your guests happy and satisfied is the key to having a successful hospitality business. Damaged facilities and closed properties lead to unhappy guests and negative feedback.”

Mike knew that he needed urgent help remediating, and selecting an inexperienced environmental consulting agency would slow the process down even further. “Some legal consultants we spoke to just did not know both sides of the picture, and that caused some problems.”, he said.

 

So why is this situation so complex that it even baffled legal experts?

Challenges

Multi-Agency Approval and Coordination

The need to obtain approvals from multiple agencies across federal, state, and local government levels, combined with the necessity to coordinate between them, significantly increased the complexity of the process.

Stakeholder Management and Jurisdictionional Complications

Identifying and managing a diverse range of stakeholders was challenging, especially given the overlapping jurisdictions and the local government's non-participation.

Regulatory Compliance and Lead Agency Absence

Adhering to California's CEQA requirements was made more difficult without the support of a lead agency. This absence not only hindered progress but also led to escalating maintenance costs without generating any revenue.

To promptly repair the damages and comply with all regulatory requirements, Equity Lifestyle Properties required an expert adept in wetland remediation, development, and navigating complex environmental and governmental regulations.

The Solution

Cox Planning's Strategic Approach

Chris Cox, CEO of Cox Planning Solutions, leveraged his extensive experience in similar situations to systematically navigate these challenges. His team’s initial focus was on understanding the diverse stakeholders and managing the complexities arising from jurisdictional overlaps and unclear roles. Recognizing the absence of a lead agency as a crucial gap, Cox steered the project through these regulatory mazes.
Innovative Lead Agency Designation and CEQA Certification

Cox Planning recognized the necessity of a lead agency for CEQA certification. They adeptly navigated the challenges posed by the Department of Housing and Community Development’s limited expertise, identifying a suitable lead agency to drive the process.

Strategic Lead Agency Designation and CEQA Certification

A pivotal strategy involved negotiating with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife to assume the lead agency role. This decision was key in overcoming the jurisdictional hurdles that had previously stalled the permitting process.

Streamlined Permitting Package Development

Their approach included efficient coordination with multiple agencies such as the Army Corps of Engineers and the Regional Water Quality Control Board. This ensured alignment of various regulatory demands and requirements, facilitating smoother project progression.

Effective Agency Coordination and Communication

Cox then prepared synchronized applications to multiple agencies, ensuring strategic planning throughout all required documents and streamlined coordination between consultants. Diligent project management resulted in combining efforts and minimizing redundancies to save time and money. 

Regulatory Support and Compliance Management

Cox Planning provided regulatory guidance and support to Equity Lifestyle's construction team, ensuring adherence to all legal and environmental standards, thus preventing potential compliance issues.

Monitoring and Reporting for Compliance Oversight

Cox Planning not only secured approvals but also actively monitored project construction, promptly addressing any issues. Their continuous monitoring and detailed reporting ensured that the project remained compliant with all environmental regulations.

Completion and Closure of Permits

They compiled comprehensive reports on the project's progress and compliance, leading to the efficient completion and closure of all permits. This ensured that Equity Lifestyle Properties remained fully compliant with all regulations, marking the successful conclusion of the project.

Chris Cox describes this approach as “a life hack on a massive scale,” which drastically reduced approval times and was pivotal in the expedited repair and reopening of Equity Lifestyle Properties ‘s park. This strategy not only overcame the initial hurdles but also set a new benchmark for handling similar projects in complex regulatory environments.

The Results

A Testament to Creativity and Expertise

Cox Planning played a crucial role in not only resolving urgent infrastructure challenges but also in enhancing the operational efficiency and reputation of Equity Lifestyle Properties.

Restoration of Essential Services

When recent storms damaged a vital water main in one of the parks, Cox Planning's swift strategic planning and expedited permit process were key in restoring the water supply. This prompt action was essential in preventing substantial revenue loss due to park downtime.

Enhancing Resident Satisfaction and Property Value

n a high-capacity RV resort outside Yosemite National Park, Cox Planning adeptly addressed long standing environmental issues. By obtaining permits for clean-up and restoration to a more natural state, they significantly improved resident satisfaction and increased the land value. This transformation positively impacted the property's reputation, shifting it from negative perceptions to a highly regarded status.

Business Continuity and Revenue Protection

Through ensuring that parks remained open and functional, Cox Planning directly contributed to the business goals of Equity Lifestyle Properties. Their effective handling of environmental and regulatory challenges safeguarded the company's continuous operation and revenue streams.

Overall, Cox Planning’s services transcended mere environmental and infrastructural solutions, playing a transformative role in the operational success and growth of Equity Lifestyle Properties in a competitive market.

Cox Planning Solutions

Where Experience Meets Innovation

The phrase “Knowledge is power” is never more true than when dealing with the bureaucracy of government agencies.

 

Cox Planning Solutions delivers success for clients by employing detailed knowledge and meticulous planning to craft streamlined processes. The simple premise of investing in the success of their clients has positioned Cox Planning Solutions to deliver strategies that save thousands of dollars and infinite headaches.

 

Cox Planning Solutions’ ability to cut through state and federal regulatory bureaucracy resulted in high-value returns for Equity Lifestyle Properties. Rather than spending years or decades negotiating with each agency separately, Equity Lifestyle Properties turned to Cox Planning Solutions. Chris Cox’s team crafted an efficient, streamlined process that braided multiple bureaucratic threads into a single solution. 

chris

Chris Cox,
CEO | Lead Strategist

Case Studies

Hidden Ridge

El Dorado County, CA

Deliverables

Biological Resources Assessment
Wetland Delineation
Rare Plant Surveys
Preconstruction Surveys
CEQA Technical Support
Clean Water Act, Section 404 Permit
Clean Water Act, Section 401 Certificate
California Waste Discharge Permit
California Lake & Streambed Agreement
Tentative Map Support

Challenges

The project site includes a stream that needed to be protected, as well as several small scattered wetlands that could not be avoided. Mitigation credits were required before permits could be finalized.

Outcome

The project was permitted and completed in 2023 and mitigation was accepted by all agencies. Our permitting solution included landscaping and construction monitoring to protect and restore the stream, saving mitigation credit purchase costs.

Lincoln Meadows

Lincoln, CA

Deliverables

Biological Resources Assessment
Wetland Delineation
Rare Plant Surveys
Protocol Surveys for Large Branchiopods
Preconstruction Surveys
CEQA Technical Support
Clean Water Act, Section 404 Permit
Clean Water Act, Section 401 Certificate
California Waste Discharge Permit
California Lake & Streambed Agreement
Tentative Map Support

Challenges

The project area is considered suitable habitat for federally listed large branchiopods (fairy shrimp). Our permitting solution combined onsite restoration and mitigation credit purchases, along with 5 years of monitoring.

Outcome

The project was approved and built in 2022. Revised site plan and agency negotiations reduced impacts and mitigation costs and streamlined local CEQA approval.

Ophir Road Self Storage Center

Placer County, CA

Deliverables

Biological Resources Assessment
Rare Plant Survey
Wetland Delineation
PCCP Approval
CEQA Support

Challenges

The project area is located in a historic stream corridor and is considered suitable habitat for several endangered species. The property also has several oak woodland areas and required extensive land cover analysis to determine development impact costs.

Outcome

Our team completed an extensive wetland delineation survey that reduced wetland areas and impact fees, followed by submission of a Placer County Conservation Program (PCCP) application.

Athens Road Hobby Condos

Lincoln, CA

Deliverables

Biological Resources Assessment
Wetland Delineation
PCCP Approval
Clean Water Act, Section 404 Permit
Clean Water Act, Section 401 Certificate
California Waste Discharge Permit
CEQA Support

Challenges

The project site includes a stream that needed to be protected, as well as several small scattered wetlands that could not be avoided. Mitigation credits were required before permits could be finalized.

Outcome

Our team obtained the 2018 permits and prepared a consistency analysis and PCCP application that were approved in 2023.

Elverta Specific Plan

Sacramento County, CA

Deliverables

Biological Resources Assessment
Wetland Delineation
Rare Plant Surveys
Protocol Surveys for Large Branchiopods
CEQA EIR Support
NEPA EIS Support
Specific Plan Approval
Clean Water Act, Section 404 Permit
Clean Water Act, Section 401 Certificate
California Waste Discharge Permit

Challenges

The approximately 1,700 acre specific plan area is proposed for residential and commercial development, but contains approximately 29 acres of 27 acres of wetlands that were assumed to be habitat for federally listed large branchiopods. Impacts required a Standard Permit with a public hearing and an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS).

Outcome

Our team worked with project engineers and EIS preparers for more than 3 years to obtain wetland and biological resource permits that were approved in 2018.

Auburn Creekside Commercial Development

Auburn, CA

Deliverables

Biological Resources Assessment
Wetland Delineation
Protocol Surveys for Red Legged Frog
Rare Plant Surveys
Preconstruction Surveys
Landscape Restoration Design
County Use Permit Support
CEQA Support
Clean Water Act, Section 404 Permit
Clean Water Act, Section 401 Certificate
California Waste Discharge Permit
California Lake & Streambed Agreement

Challenges

The project requires a bridge to be built over the creek and floodplain that flow through the middle of the property. Detailed permitting was needed to approve the bridge piers and dewatering system. Rare plants were found onsite and required a relocation plan and mitigation purchase.

Outcome

Our team negotiated a streamlined mitigation agreement with a local preserve that satisfied all requirements. The project was successfully permitted and is awaiting the start of construction in 2024.

El Dorado Hills Town Center

El Dorado Hills, CA

Deliverables

Biological Resources Assessment
Wetland Delineation
Preconstruction Surveys
CEQA Support
County Use Permit Support
Clean Water Act, Section 404 Permit
Clean Water Act, Section 401 Certificate
California Waste Discharge Permit
California Lake & Streambed Agreement

Challenges

Detailed analysis was required to determine how to accommodate several large commercial sites while maintaining wetland and habitat connectivity. Mitigation credits and offsite mitigation were also required to obtain permit approvals.

Outcome

Our team located and negotiated competitive mitigation credit purchases and oversaw offsite mitigation installation. The town center is now built out and accommodates a majority of the commercial business in El Dorado County.

Foothill Blvd. Commercial Complex

Roseville, CA

Deliverables

Biological Resources Assessment
Wetland Delineation
Preconstruction Surveys
CEQA Support
Clean Water Act, Section 404 Permit
Clean Water Act, Section 401 Certificate
California Waste Discharge Permit
California Lake & Streambed Agreement

Challenges

This property contained a wetland and drainage area created by previous development activity.

Outcome

Our team successfully obtained a delineation determination indicating the depression was man-made and did not require a permit. We then completed required permits for the drainage. The project is now built.

De Anza Residential Community

Santa Cruz, CA

Deliverables

Biological Resources Assessment
Wetland Delineation
Rare Plant Surveys
Landscape Restoration Design
Preconstruction Surveys
City Development Permit
CEQA Analysis
Coastal Development Permit
Clean Water Act, Section 404 Permit
Clean Water Act, Section 401 Certificate
California Waste Discharge Permit
California Lake & Streambed Agreement

Challenges

The community is located on the Pacific coast and is suitable habitat for more than 70 special status species. Residents were angry coastal development conditions from the 1970’s had not been met. A coastal development permit with a public hearing was required in addition to other permits.

Outcome

In addition to successfully obtaining all permits and managing landscape restoration, our team led a public relations effort on behalf of our client to win over residents.

Yosemite RV and Camp Resort

Tuolumne County, CA

Deliverables

Biological Resources Assessment
Wetland Delineation
Rare Plant Surveys
Fish Survey
Preconstruction Surveys
HCD Development Permit
CEQA Support
Clean Water Act, Section 404 Permit
Clean Water Act, Section 401 Certificate
California Waste Discharge Permit
California Lake & Streambed Agreement

Challenges

The South Fork Tuolumne River is suitable habitat for migratory fish and is considered a wild and scenic river. The pedestrian bridge and retaining wall required extensive repairs to prevent them from falling in the river. The onsite water treatment facility required a water rights analysis. Construction required partially damming the river.

Outcome

Our team successfully negotiated with the County and the Department of Fish & Wildlife to issue a CEQA exemption, which allowed permit approval and construction. We also obtained approval for the treatment center to provide drinking water.

Let’s Get in Touch

Address

1510 J Street, Ste. #100
Sacramento, CA 95814

Working Hours

Weekdays: 9:00am - 5:00pm
Weekends: Closed

Phone & Email Address

E: info@coxplanningsolutions.com
p: 916.758.8470